Trouble viewing this email? Read it online


cummings-logo-2013 (2).jpg
 


Welcome to Crypto Megabytes, a short note on a relevant issue in the crypto currencies world.

If you would like to discuss any of the points we raise below, please contact me or one of our other lawyers.  

claire-cummings.jpg

Claire Cummings

020 7585 1406

claire.cummings@cummingslaw.com
www.cummingslaw.com


 

CRYPTO MEGABYTES

Cryptoassets Taskforce: final report


The final report of the joint HM Treasury, FCA and-Bank of England Cryptoassets Taskforce was recently published and sets out the UK’s approach to cryptoassets and distributed ledger technology (DLT) in financial services.  The report provides an overview of cryptoassets and the underlying technology, assesses the associated risks and potential benefits, and sets out the path forward with respect to regulation in the UK.  The Taskforce has concluded that while DLT is at an early stage of development, it has the potential to deliver significant benefits in financial services and other sectors in the future, and all three authorities will continue to support its development.

The report notes there is limited evidence of the current generation of cryptoassets delivering benefits, however, benefits may arise in the future.  In contrast, there are substantial potential risks associated with cryptoassets and the highest priority for the authorities are to mitigate the risks to consumers and market integrity, and to prevent the use of cryptoassets for illicit activity.  The Taskforce has concluded that strong action should be taken to address the risks associated with cryptoassets that fall within existing regulatory frameworks. Further consultation and international coordination is required for those cryptoassets that pose new challenges to traditional forms of financial regulation, and fall outside the existing regulatory framework. The authorities plan to engage with international bodies to ensure a comprehensive response.

The Taskforce’s cryptoassets framework

The Taskforce has developed a framework which takes into account the different uses of the three different types of cryptoassets (exchange tokens, security tokens and utility tokens).  Cryptoassets are typically used:
  • as a means of exchange;

  • for investment; and/or

  • to support capital raising and/or the creation of decentralised networks through initial coin offerings (ICOs)

The Taskforce found that cryptoassets are not widely used as a means of exchange in the UK. Data from cryptoasset exchanges shows that trading of sterling against Bitcoin makes up just 0.33% of daily global trade volumes – however the report also notes that the pseudonymous nature of cryptoassets makes such data difficult to obtain.  The Taskforce estimated that there are 56 ICO projects in the UK that have been used for capital formation, which accounts for 4.3% of the 983 projects globally. 

The current regulatory perimeter

Whether and what regulation applies to a particular cryptoasset instrument or activity can only be decided on a case-by-case basis.  Firms and persons involved in providing services or investments related to cryptoassets should carefully consider if their activities could involve regulated activities or the issuing of financial promotions, and must ensure they are complying with relevant legal and regulatory obligations.  

The FCA has been conducting enquiries into activities of unauthorised firms that are involved in some form of cryptoassets business to determine whether they are carrying on regulated activities that require FCA authorisation. If so, the FCA may investigate and take action, identifying and determining the most serious matters which pose the greatest risk to consumers. The FCA has also been encouraging regulated firms to speak to the FCA supervisors regarding cryptoasset activities they are undertaking or considering.  In addition, financial services law is not the only potentially applicable body of laws. For example, contract law, consumer law, and advertising standards may apply.

There are also broader considerations for regulated firms that carry out cryptoasset-related activities. Some regulatory provisions in the FCA’s Handbook – such as the Principles for Business, the Senior Managers and Certification Regime, the Systems and Controls Provisions, and the Financial Promotions rules – can apply to unregulated activities in certain contexts.

In addition to the Financial Promotions rules placed on regulated firms, there are also broader legislative restrictions in respect of financial promotions. Section 21 of FSMA provides that a person must not, in the course of business, communicate an invitation or inducement to engage in investment activity unless the promotion has been made or approved by an authorised person or it is exempt. Issuing a financial promotion in breach of Section 21 of FSMA is a criminal offence.

Security tokens and other similar products

While security tokens fall within the current regulatory perimeter and it is the responsibility of firms to determine whether their activities require authorisation, the Taskforce recognises that the complexity and opacity of many cryptoassets means it is difficult to determine whether they qualify as security tokens.  Given the complexity and variety of cryptoasset products intended to function as investments, the Taskforce is concerned that there is not sufficient consistency of regulatory application in these circumstances.

Exchange tokens

While security tokens are a new form of an existing financial instrument, the Taskforce considers that exchange tokens do not meet the traditional definition of a financial instrument.  These assets are unlike other financial services products, and do not fit neatly within existing definitions or financial regulatory frameworks.

Impacts of DLT

The Taskforce considers that DLT has the potential to deliver significant benefits in financial services, as well as in a broad range of other sectors. As an emerging leader in DLT, the UK should look to capitalise on these opportunities.  DLT has the potential to enhance system resilience; improve the efficiency of end-to-end settlement processes and reporting, auditing and oversight; and enable greater automation.  The Taskforce does not consider there to be regulatory barriers to the adoption of DLT. The PRA and FCA will continue to take a technologically neutral approach to regulation, as well as providing a platform for innovation.

Impacts of cryptoassets

Cryptoassets are not widely used in the UK, and the UK is not a major market relative to the global cryptoasset market. However, interest and activity in cryptoassets in the UK has grown over the past few years. The Taskforce has assessed a wide range of potential benefits and risks associated with cryptoassets. It has concluded that there is limited evidence of the current generation of cryptoassets delivering benefits. However, benefits may materialise in the future, for example through the use of ICOs as a capital raising tool. The Taskforce has concluded that cryptoassets pose a range of risks, notably to consumers (who may face large losses), market integrity (due to manipulation and other market-abuse style strategies) and financial crime. While cryptoassets currently pose no material risks to financial stability, this may change in the future.

Summary

The Taskforce has concluded that DLT has the potential to deliver significant benefits in both financial services and other sectors, and all three authorities will continue to support its development. 

HM Treasury, the FCA and the Bank of England will take action to mitigate the risks that cryptoassets pose to consumers and market integrity; to prevent the use of cryptoassets for illicit activity; to guard against threats to financial stability that could emerge in the future; and to encourage responsible development of legitimate DLT and cryptoasset-related activity in the UK. 

In order to deliver
 these actions, the authorities will consult on: 
  • implementing one of the most comprehensive responses globally to the use of cryptoassets for illicit activity 

  • a potential prohibition of the sale to retail consumers of derivatives referencing certain types of cryptoassets (for example, exchange tokens)1, including CFDs, options, futures and transferable securities 

  • guidance clarifying how certain cryptoassets already fall within the existing regulatory perimeter 

  • whether the regulatory perimeter requires extension in relation to cryptoassets that have comparable features to specified investments but that fall outside the perimeter 


The Taskforce has also concluded that exchange tokens present new challenges to traditional forms of financial regulation. There is therefore a need to consider carefully how regulation could meaningfully and effectively address the risks posed by exchange tokens and what, if any, regulatory tools would be most appropriate. The government will issue a consultation in early 2019 to further explore whether and how exchange tokens and related firms such as exchanges and wallet providers could be regulated effectively, in the case that other measures outlined in this report do not adequately address all relevant risks. 
In addition, the authorities will continue to:
 
  • warn consumers of the risks of investing in cryptoassets 
  • monitor potential implications for financial stability
 

This document is for general guidance only. It does not contain definitive advice.

 



Follow us

block-divider.jpg

You regularly receive communications from Cummings Law Ltd ("Cummings") relating to legal updates, invitations to events and other information that may be of interest to you. We believe that we have a legitimate interest in sending these to you and in order to do so we hold your personal data on our database. It is our responsibility to provide you with our privacy policy, which governs the communications that we send to you. In our privacy policy, you will find details about how we use your personal data and how you can exercise your rights in relation to it. If you would prefer not to receive our emails please unsubscribe here or below or at any time by clicking the unsubscribe link which is located at the bottom of every email we send to you.

We   have taken great care to ensure the accuracy of this version of Crypto Megabytes.   However, Crypto Megabytes is written in general terms and you are strongly recommended to seek specific advice before taking any action based on the   information it contains. No responsibility can be taken for any loss arising from, action taken or refrained from on the basis of this publication. If you   would like to be removed from the mailing list of this publication please click unsubscribe below. Nothing within this communication may be copied, re-printed or similar without prior written permission from Cummings.

Authorised  and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority. Please contact us if you would like to arrange a meeting. This message (including any attachments) from the law firm of Cummings is confidential and may contain information which is proprietary, privileged or otherwise legally protected against unauthorised use or disclosure. If you are not the intended recipient, please do not read, copy, distribute, disclose or otherwise use or place any reliance on any information in this message or any attachments; and please alert the sender by return e-mail, delete this message and any attachments from your system and destroy any hard copies. Neither Cummings nor the sender accepts liability for any corruption, interception or unauthorized amendment of messages or attachments transmitted by e-mail. It is your responsibility to scan this message and any attachments for computer viruses in accordance with good working practice. The firm is not authorised by the Financial Conduct Authority, but is authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority (for the code of conduct please see www.sra.org.uk/rules) and undertakes certain activities in relation to investments which are limited in scope and incidental to its legal services or which may reasonably be regarded as a necessary part of its legal services.

Cummings

Tel: + 44 20 7585 1406
Mob: + 44 7734 057 327

Cummings Law
42 Brook Street
London Greater London W1K 5DB
United Kingdom

www.cummingslaw.com

19 12 2018

 
 

Subscribe a friend | Unsubscribe

 

 

email sent by multimail

REPORT ABUSE